Tuesday, October 30, 2007

Why So Few Iraq War Protest Songs?

[See URL for numerous embedded links.]

Why So Few Iraq War Protest Songs?


October 26, 2007
By Joe Guzzardi

During a five-hour drive back to Lodi from Cayucos on California's
central coast, I happened on to XM Radio's special broadcast,
"Protest Songs of the '60s"

Listening again to those powerful songs ---Bob Dylan's Blowin' in the
Wind, Creedence Clearwater Revival's Fortunate Son, John Lennon's
Imagine (YouTube.com video here) and Give Peace A Chance (video here)
and The Animals' We Gotta Get Out of This Place, took me back to when
I was a young man living in New York.

During those turbulent years from 1963-1975, protest against the
Vietnam War built, distrust of Presidents Lyndon Johnson and Richard
Nixon intensified and flower children gathered across the nation to
call for an overhaul to the broken political system.

Today, more than four decades later, many parallels to the '60s
exist. Opposition to the Iraq War has steadily increased, President
Bush's popularity has sunk to historic lows and Americans are
disgusted with the nation's direction.

The biggest difference between then and now is that protest songs
about death and dying which played an important role in raising
awareness about the Vietnam tragedy and eventually changed public
opinion about the war's validity are largely missing.

One exception is Bruce Springsteen's tribute album, The Seeger
Sessions: We Shall Overcome.

Another is Pearl Jam's hit, World Wide Suicide, which told of a
mother mourning her son killed in an Iraq battle because his was "a
life the president took for granted."

But the Vietnam songbook was more extensive than today's handful of
Iraq-related singles.

As a testimony to that era, on March 1st 2003, with the Iraq War
looming, Joe's Pub at the Public Theater in New York presented the
Vietnam Songbook---a collection of over 100 tunes critical of the
Vietnam War. (Read the review here.)

Readers who struggled through the Vietnam years would instantly
recognize nearly all of those 100. Many are still in rotation on
mainstream radio.

Here are three:

---Ohio, written by Neil Young "immediately" (in his words) after
seeing the Life Magazine cover of four dead Kent State University
students and originally performed by Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young
may be the most important protest song ever written. The song, banned
from many stations because it named Nixon in its lyrics, served as an
anthem for disaffected students throughout the country.

---Marvin Gaye's What Goin' On The title song from the 1971 album of
the same name was an instant smash and is considered one of pop
music's landmarks. The album is told from the perspective of a
Vietnam vet veteran coming home to the country he had been fighting
for, and seeing injustice, suffering and hatred. Gaye's brother,
Frankie, had returned from three years of service in the Army in 1970.

---Barry McGuire's The Eve of Destruction reached #1 on Billboard in
September 1965. With its most famous lyrics "You're old enough to
kill, but not for votin'/ You don't believe in war, but what's that
gun you're totin?' the song summarized the frustration of young
soldiers sent to Southeast Asia to fight in an unpopular war.

Today's protest songs are narrowly focused on President Bush and not
specifically on Iraq.

The head music critic for Entertainment Weekly, David Browne said:
"For better or worse, Bush has stirred up a lot of vitriol in the
music community. There's always been protest songs against
presidents, but they have never been near to the level of venom
you're seeing now." [Protest Song Is Back---With a Vengeance, By
Christopher Blagg, Christian Science Monitor, June 4, 2004]

I'm not clear on why there aren't more angry songs about our soldiers
being killed on the Iraq and Afghanistan battlefields. Record company
executives, artists and the young demographic that buys music are
liberal and opposed to the war.

And from a strictly commercial viewpoint, the anti-Vietnam songs
charted and were moneymakers.

The only explanation I can come up with saddens me.

During Vietnam, the draft made every family with a son of age
vulnerable. We all knew someone, somewhere who was off to Vietnam.

But today's volunteer army shields most of us from losing a loved one.

Apparently, other people's lives are cheaper than our own.

Joe Guzzardi [email him], an instructor in English at the Lodi Adult
School, has been writing a weekly column since 1988. It currently
appears in the Lodi News-Sentinel.



Sean said...

Actually, the entertainment media is saturated with far more anti-war protest songs than in the 1960s and 1970s. And the differences is, this time, Pop is leading the way in protest music. Some of the most popular songs of the past 5 years have been John Mayer's "Waiting on the World to Change", the Dixie Chicks "Not Ready to Make Nice", Greenday's entire multiplatinum "American Idiot" album, and the Black-Eyed Peas song "Where is the Love". Just off the top of my head, I've named more protest songs from 2003-2006 than EVER charted on the Billboard Hot 100 in the 1960s and 1970s. You can say it doesn't matter, because they're Pop songs, but I say the folk songs of Bob Dylan and other folkrockers of the 1970s didn't matter. Music is only indicative of, and able to affect American culture if more than a few thousand people at a music festival are hearing it. It is a common misconception that Bob Dylan, Marvin Gaye, and similar artists had popular anti war songs in the Vietnam era. It's just not true. Only their non-political songs ever got attention, until recently. 4 antiwar songs charted on the Billboard Hot 100 from 1963-1972. Already, 7 have from 2003-2007.

ryan said...

Perhaps... but the songs from the 60s and 70s are far better songs. They are VERY powerful songs; which allows them to hold up under the terms of memorability. Seriously? The Dixie Chicks? Who would seriously jump out of their seat and take to the street in protest because of their influence? I would much rather listen to Bob Dylan talk about concluded wars than the Dixie Chicks whining about Bush. Besides, most protest songs from the 60s are still applicable today. But I personally know that there exists a Dylan song for any poltical, cultural, or counter-cultural movement. The Civil Rights Movement anyone? I know that Bob Dylan was an avid supporter of Dr. King. Most of these are just my opinions of course... feel free to ignore. You were born with that right. Those rights were born with America. Protest songs keep those rights alive in the hearts of the politicians and the people. ^_^