A synthetic substitute for marijuana is drawing raves and warnings.
It's 3:40 p.m., and Paschal High School in Fort Worth, Texas is
letting out. The kids scatter, heading home to study or play sports
or chill out. But some of the school's brightest and most promising
students make a shorter trip. They cross East Berry Street to the
local head shop to pick up three grams of its most popular product.
The shop, Fusion, has the usual glass cases full of pipes and papers,
ashtrays, and candles. Black lights bounce off the posters and
T-shirts for sale. Most of the young after-school smokers head home
with their purchases, but others relax on the back room's black
couches, getting high in the hazy comfort of the hookah lounge. The
stuff that's flying off the shelves of head shops all over the
country goes by brand names like K2, Spice Gold, and Hawaiian Haze,
and it's replacing marijuana in the lives of student athletes, police
officers, and stoners who just don't want to get caught breaking the
law. What they're smoking is billed as an herbal incense, but the
herbs in this case have been sprayed with one or more compounds that
are the synthetic equivalent of THC the compound in marijuana that
gets you high.
The three-gram packages go for $40 to $50 and are marked as being
"not for human consumption." But that's just another one of those
lies that are the basis of head shops: The bongs are just decorative
objects, the papers are for rolling tobacco cigarettes and K2 is
not for smoking. The shop owner, Walt (he didn't want his last name
used), said that the use of K2 going on at his business doesn't
violate the "no-consumption" admonition because it is being
"vaporized" and not smoked. Technically, he may be right, but the
distinction doesn't mean much to most K2 fans.
"K2 is the most phenomenal thing that has ever happened to this
business," Walt says. "Even though it just started getting popular in
the last month of 2009, it is definitely the best product of the decade."
If the profits are fantastic for the people who sell K2, the news
isn't necessarily all that great for the buyers. It can cost up to
twice as much as low-grade marijuana, and most users say its high
lasts an hour at most. The quality of the buzz that it provides can
also be uneven. But the irony is that while brands like K2 are
providing for now a legal way for folks to get high, it could be
more dangerous to their health than smoking marijuana. It's enough to
harsh the buzz of any K2 smoker.
As with street drugs, it's almost impossible for buyers to tell just
what compounds are in K2. And regardless of which synthetic cocktail
has been sprayed on the "incense," the effects have not been studied in humans.
A national debate has begun over whether the hopped-up herbs are
dangerous. Some states and nine European countries have already
banned the stuff. The U.S. military has forbidden servicemen and
servicewomen from using the compounds.
That debate has had some interesting side effects of its own
detractors of the chemically enhanced herbs say the dangers of the
unnatural stuff are another argument for why good ol' marijuana
itself should be legalized.
"We simply don't know what the health effects might be," Clemson
University professor John W. Huffman says about the synthetic
compounds. He should know. He's one of the guys who helped invent the
products that others are now selling as the latest thing in the
science of getting high.
Anthony, 20, is a Fort Worth restaurant worker who is on probation
for an aggravated robbery he committed at a fast-food restaurant
while he was in high school. He served 23 months in jail and got out
last year. He didn't want his last name used.
As part of his probation, he must undergo twice-monthly drug tests.
He will be on probation until 2018, and he figured he would never get
high again. That was until about three weeks ago, when he started smoking K2.
"I had heard about it from some friends, and because it is legal, I
had no problem trying it," Anthony says. "It is not as strong as real
pot, but I think it is more mental than physical, like pot can be. It
doesn't last as long, but I do like to do it before work, because it
gives me so much more energy."
Walt, the head shop owner, says he's selling more than $500 a day of
the synthetic-sprayed herbs. And he is surprised by who buys the stuff.
"We have a lot of police officers, military personnel, probation
officers, folks who might be subject to drug tests," he says. "We are
… starting to have some parents coming in to see what their kids are
smoking," he says. "And what is interesting is they come back for
more because they like it."
Scientists say the psychoactive powers of the synthetic weed are four
to five times greater than marijuana. But the people interviewed for
this story who are regular users of this fake pot disagree as did
the **Fort Worth Weekly**'s test panel. They say the high is much
shorter and not as strong as with regular weed. "It hits you
immediately but only lasts 45 minutes to an hour at most," says one
Paschal High senior. "After your high ends, however, you feel 100
percent back to normal," she says, "unlike with weed where your high
will go away but you don't feel sober for the rest of the day."
Another senior says he felt "less paranoid on K2 than I am on weed. I
feel more in control of myself when I'm on K2. I also think more
clearly, because weed makes me go off on mental tangents."
A third classmate says K2 and weed provide "different kinds of high.
After I come down off the high with weed, I feel tired and lazy. In
contrast, when I come off the high of K2, I feel really productive
and get things done. I drive better on K2. I get the munchies,
though, after smoking both."
The idea of high school kids debating whether they are more efficient
drivers while high on marijuana or K2 makes parents and cops blanch,
of course especially since, in the case of K2, there is no real
scientific evidence of its effects on people.
"These THC synthetic compounds affect movement and perception and the
ability to react. But again, this has moved up on us so quickly that
we really don't know what effects it will have on people," says
Marilyn Huestis, a chemist for the National Institute on Drug Abuse.
The synthetic chemicals used in the fake-weed mixtures were
originally developed by medical researchers looking for new pain
medications. The herbal mixtures first surfaced in Europe around
2006, according to news reports.
Huffman, at Clemson, is one of the leading researchers in the field.
For decades, he worked to develop synthetic cannabinoids, chemicals
that would bind to specific brain receptors much as THC does and
possibly help alleviate pain. One of the synthetics he developed in
1994 was named JWH-018; it's now one of the most popular compounds
used in the fake pot. But the synthetic THC compounds have been
tested only on animals.
"Evidently, some people have figured out how to make them [the
synthetic compounds] and are putting them in products marketed as
incense," says Huffman, 77, who has won the National Institutes of
Health's Senior Scientist Award. In a statement released last week by
Clemson, in response to a barrage of news media questions, Huffman
says that the synthetic cannabinoids "could very well have toxic
effects" in humans. … I would emphasize the risk people are taking
when they smoke these products."
There are now more than 100 versions of the fake-THC compounds out
there, and the fact that they are used in many different combinations
makes the untested nature of the substances even chancier. German
researchers who tested seven incense products found five different
compounds in varying combinations and with widely varying levels of
the psychoactive ingredients.
Huestis says the issue of legal fake pot appeared on her radar screen
about a year ago. "There are a lot of issues here, but the major one
is that no one using this stuff knows what they are getting," she
says. "Some [products] are very powerful, some have very little of
the drug in them."
She says that studies on the synthetic cannabinoids could take a long
time. First they would be tested in animals, then in different human
groups. After that, scientists would make recommendations on whether
some of the compounds should be made subject to the Controlled Substances Act.
"But this will be very difficult to do," Huestis says. "Right now
most labs cannot even identify these compounds. And testing more than
100 of these chemicals will take time and be very costly. And the
people who are making these compounds might just change it by adding
or removing one atom."
In Delaware last month, police and paramedics were called to a house
where they found two young men and a young woman in severe physical
distress after smoking the fake pot. They were suffering from
breathing troubles, heart palpitations, and projectile vomiting. They
were taken to the emergency room. Just a few weeks ago an Oklahoma
teenager developed similar symptoms at his high school after smoking
the incense off campus.
Dr. Anthony Scalzo, a professor of toxicology at Saint Louis
University, says he has seen nearly 30 cases involving teenagers who
were experiencing hallucinations, elevated heart rate and blood
pressure, and vomiting after smoking the fake weed.
"These toxic chemicals are neither natural nor safe," Scalzo says.
Because the K2 craze has spread so fast, people who have concerns
about it are having to learn fast. John Haenes, who works as a
substance abuse counselor for Tarrant County Challenge Inc., a
private Texas nonprofit that coordinates substance abuse programs and
education, says parents are largely unaware of their children's use
of fake pot.
"We need to educate them as much as possible, because any drug these
kids take can have large negative effects," he says.
Debbie Meripolski, executive director of the Dallas Council of
Alcohol and Drug Abuse, met with law enforcement officials and
substance abuse counselors last week to talk about the fake weed. "A
lot of the people in our meeting were quite surprised about what is
happening now," she says, even though they deal with youth
substance-abuse problems on a daily basis.
The DEA is looking closely at the issue. "Synthetic and designer
drugs are definitely on the DEA's radar, as we are seeing several
indications that these THC-like substances could be a significant
problem both domestically and internationally," says DEA spokeswoman
Authorities aren't sure who is producing the fake weed or where,
though most news reports mention China as a leading candidate. Dozens
of distributors in this country advertise the compounds on their own
web sites, and through alternative newspapers like this one. (There
are no vendors currently advertising K2 in Orlando Weekly, though
some advertisers do stock the product.) One company web site says the
particular compound it offers "is only sold as a fertilizer and for
research." Calls and e-mails to several of the companies Innovative
Products, EARTH Fantastick, and Extraordinary Transformation were
not returned. Here in Orlando, K2 is regularly stocked at head shops
like Pipe Dreams and Father Nature's. Owners of both stores did not
return calls for comment.
Because the THC-like compounds are considered untested drugs, the
U.S. Food and Drug Administration has banned them from being
imported. But the purveyors of K2 are staying ahead of the
feds: Fusion now stocks a product produced in the U.S. and
distributed by a company in Dallas and that therefore isn't
affected by import questions.
Texas state Rep. Lon Burnam is one of those who believes that the
illegality of pot is forcing young people into using a potentially
more toxic drug.
"What little I know about this stuff is very scary," the Fort Worth
Democrat says. "I am appalled that high school kids in my district
and across the state are using it. People are always going to get
high with something or other, but we are driving kids to the unknown,
which might be very dangerous.
"This broad use of K2 is just one more reason to legalize marijuana
in some ways," Burnam says. "Because with K2, we don't know what the
side effects are. With marijuana we do."
Drug foes don't buy that argument.
"Just because kids are dabbling with this new drug doesn't mean we
should legalize marijuana," says Calvina Fay, executive director of
the Drug Free America Foundation. "The fact is, marijuana is harmful.
It has a link with some forms of mental illness. Legalizing it would
be a horrible mistake. What we need to do is study these synthetic
THC drugs and see if they should be made illegal as well."
Paul Armentano, deputy director of the National Organization for the
Reform of Marijuana Laws, says that he's never seen K2 in head shops
in his state of California and doesn't know anyone who uses it. He
believes that is because marijuana possession has been largely
"Making marijuana illegal has the effect of pushing this market to an
unknown drug [for which] we don't know the risks," he says.
"We're in a tough position because it is legal, and law enforcement
is not involved," Meripolski says. "But we have to do something,
because this is a mind-altering drug that affects everything from
driving to social disorders to just doing their school work well. We
have to address this issue with education. But maybe the state might
need to step in and ban it."
Kansas and Missouri have already banned it, and bills to do the same
are pending in Illinois and Georgia. Could Texas join that group? "I
expect this will be a big issue when the legislature convenes next
January," Burnam says.
Florida, meanwhile, has had its sights firmly set on head shops for
awhile, most recently with a bill working its way through both houses
in the current legislative session. HB 187 and its companion, SB 366,
both seek to place limits on just who can sell smoking paraphernalia.
If it becomes a law, water pipe retailers will be forced to prove
that a minimum of 75 percent of their total sales come from tobacco
transactions. But the bill makes no mention of synthetic weed
products, just the pipes used to smoke real drugs.
State Rep. Scott Plakon, R-Longwood, made waves in last year's
session with a bill that would ban the retail sale of novelty
lighters (that bill died in committee), but when asked about the
existence of K2 in Central Florida, he says he's never heard of it.
Well, now he has.
"That could be something we might want to tack on as an amendment," he says.